Skip to content
SkillPass

What Is Mentoring? Definition, Types and How It Works

Mentoring is a working relationship in which a more experienced person, the mentor, supports a less experienced person, the mentee, over several months with regular conversations, advice drawn from their own experience and access to their network. Companies use it for onboarding, developing future leaders, succession and knowledge transfer. Unlike coaching, a mentor passes on what they have learned instead of only asking questions. But mentoring takes time, depends on two people and leaves nothing in writing unless someone takes notes.

Author: Kevin Baur BSc

Published on

Contents
Title card: Mentoring, passing on experience at work

Most people can name someone who taught them more at work than any course did. Mentoring turns that lucky break into a planned method. This guide explains what mentoring means, how it differs from coaching and job shadowing, the main types, how to set up a mentoring program in six steps and what happens when the mentor leaves.

What is mentoring?

Mentoring is a learning relationship between two people with different levels of experience. The mentor shares knowledge, experience and contacts. The mentee brings questions, goals and real situations from their own work. They meet regularly, usually over several months.

There is no single definition. The English Wikipedia article on mentorship notes that more than 50 definitions are in use. A widely quoted one comes from Bozeman and Feeney: mentoring is the informal transmission of knowledge, social capital and psychosocial support that the recipient sees as relevant to work, career or professional development, usually face to face and over a sustained period.

The word comes from Homer's Odyssey. Mentor is a trusted friend of Odysseus who looks after his household while he is away at the Trojan War. Later the goddess Athena takes Mentor's form to guide Odysseus's son Telemachus on his journey. The name became the word for an experienced adviser.

What a mentor actually does

Research summarized on Wikipedia names two main kinds of support: psychosocial support, such as encouraging and listening, and career support, such as advice and discussing goals. Role modeling and knowledge transfer are named as further functions. Day to day, that means:

  • Sharing experience: how a decision was made, what went wrong last time, what a particular client cares about.
  • Explaining the unwritten rules: who really decides and which route is faster than the official one.
  • Opening doors: making introductions and bringing the mentee along to meetings.
  • Giving feedback: honest, and without it turning into a performance review.
  • Listening: a safe place for questions the mentee would not ask their own manager.

That is why it often makes sense not to pick the mentee's direct manager as the mentor. Someone who rates your performance, has a say in your pay or assigns your work hears fewer open questions and honest doubts.

Mentoring vs coaching vs job shadowing

How mentoring differs from related ways of learning at work
MethodWho supports youTypical lengthWhat it is about
MentoringAn experienced person from the company or the industryMonths to yearsExperience, advice, contacts and growth
CoachingA trained coach, often external and paidA limited number of sessionsOne or two development goals; the coachee finds their own answers
Job shadowingA colleague whose work you followDays to weeksWatching real work, then doing it yourself
OnboardingManager, buddy and teamThe first weeks to monthsTasks, processes and tools of the new role
TrainingA trainerHours to daysOne set topic for a group

Asana's guide to finding a mentor puts the difference this way: a coach is a paid role, usually focused on one or two areas of development, while a mentor does not charge and the relationship is less formal. In practice the lines blur. Good mentors ask questions too instead of only handing out answers, and some mentoring starts with a few days of job shadowing so the mentor can see what the mentee is really working on.

Types of mentoring

The main types of mentoring and when each one fits
TypeHow it worksGood for
One to one mentoringOne experienced person supports one menteeDevelopment, succession, knowledge transfer
Group mentoring and mentoring circlesOne mentor or a mixed group meets several mentees around a topicMany new hires and few experienced people
Peer mentoringColleagues in similar roles help each otherExchange, new teams
Reverse mentoringYounger employees mentor senior ones, for example on digital tools and social mediaDigital topics, fresh perspectives
Situational mentoringA short relationship for one specific purpose or skillA defined gap, such as a new tool

Across all of these sits the question of how much structure there is. A formal program is run by the company: it has a set length, goals and someone who matches mentors and mentees. Informal mentoring grows on its own and lasts as long as both people find it useful. A study of 1,162 employees cited on Wikipedia found that satisfaction with the mentoring relationship had a stronger effect on attitudes than simply having a mentor, or than the design of the formal program. The quality of the relationship matters more than the program around it.

What companies use mentoring for

  • Onboarding: new hires get a fixed contact besides their manager. The onboarding guide shows how that fits into the first weeks.
  • Developing future leaders: people moving into leadership learn from those already in the role how decisions get made and how hard conversations go.
  • Succession: whoever is lined up for a key role learns it over months from the person in it today, which makes mentoring part of succession planning.
  • Knowledge transfer before retirement: experienced employees pass on what no handbook contains. The guide to knowledge transfer before retirement shows how to plan it.

How to set up a mentoring program in six steps

1. Set a clear goal

Write down in one sentence what should be different afterwards. For example: "Within twelve months the mentee prices and negotiates key account offers on her own." "Grow professionally" can be neither planned nor checked.

2. Match mentors and mentees

Both sides should take part voluntarily. Match people on the mentee's goal, not only on rapport or department. And do not just ask mentors whether they have the experience; ask whether they have the time over the next few months.

3. Agree on the format

Put a short agreement in writing: the length, for example six or twelve months, how often you meet, for example an hour every two to four weeks, what stays confidential and how either side can end the mentoring if it does not work.

4. Hold the conversations

The mentee prepares each meeting and brings a real situation: a difficult conversation, a decision, a project. The mentor explains how they would handle it and, above all, why. The reasoning is worth more than the answer.

5. Write down what is learned

This is the step most often skipped. After each meeting the mentee notes in their own words what they learned: rules of thumb for decisions, contacts, experience with clients or suppliers. Recurring tasks become a standard operating procedure like the ones in these SOP examples. Otherwise the knowledge just moves from one head to another.

6. Review and close

At the end, review together: was the goal reached, what helped and what did not? A deliberate close keeps the mentoring from fading out, and feedback from both sides improves the next round.

Questions to ask your mentor

These questions aim at the experience that is not written down anywhere:

  • How would you have handled this situation, and why that way?
  • Which decision from your first years would you make differently today?
  • How do you spot early that a project is going wrong?
  • Who should I get to know in the company, and why?
  • Which unwritten rules apply here?
  • What do you know about our most important clients that is not in any system?
  • What happens only once a year, and what do I need to watch for then?
  • What should I learn next?

The gap: mentoring does not keep knowledge

Mentoring is one of the strongest ways to pass on tacit knowledge: judgment, experience and a feel for people. That is exactly why it has a weakness that is easy to miss. What the mentor passes on ends up in the mentee's head, not in the company. If the mentee moves on, it is gone again. If the mentor leaves earlier than planned, the mentoring stays half finished.

That is why mentoring works best combined with other methods. The guide to knowledge transfer compares the main ones, from job shadowing to interviews. A skills matrix shows which tasks only one person can do today, and the guide to tribal knowledge explains why that becomes a risk.

Common mistakes

  • No goal: the meetings are pleasant, but nobody knows what they are for.
  • Mentors without time: meetings get cancelled until the mentoring quietly ends.
  • The manager as mentor: the mentee only says what will go down well.
  • Only talking: nothing gets written down, and the knowledge is as fragile as before.
  • No end date: without a set length and a close, nobody ever takes stock.

Bottom line

Mentoring is one of the most direct ways to pass on experience. It works with a clear goal, willing participants, an agreed format and a proper close, and it is worth far more when the mentee writes down what they learn. Where there is no time for mentoring because a key person is about to leave, capture their knowledge another way before they go.

Frequently asked questions

What is the simple definition of mentoring?
Mentoring is when a more experienced person supports a less experienced one over a longer period by sharing knowledge, experience and contacts. The experienced person is the mentor, the person being supported is the mentee. At work it is mainly used for onboarding, development and succession.
What is the difference between mentoring and coaching?
A mentor shares their own experience and usually comes from the same company or industry, typically without being paid for it. A coach is usually trained and paid, focuses on one or two development goals and helps the coachee find their own answers rather than giving them. Mentoring tends to run for months, coaching for a limited number of sessions.
How long does mentoring last?
There is no fixed length. Formal programs often run for an agreed period, for example six or twelve months, with a meeting every few weeks. Informal mentoring lasts as long as both people find it useful, sometimes for years.
What is reverse mentoring?
In reverse mentoring the roles are swapped: a younger or less senior employee mentors a more senior one, for example on digital tools, social media or new ways of working. Both sides learn from each other.
Is mentoring enough to keep knowledge in a company?
Not on its own. Mentoring passes knowledge from one person to another, but the company has nothing in writing afterwards. Combine it with notes, standard operating procedures and a handover document so the knowledge stays even when the mentee moves on.

Sources

Back to overview